Naturaily logo with transparent background

Why Is Your Website's Search Costing You Sales? How Algolia + Next.js Can Turn Queries into Revenue

Every search query is a customer literally telling you what they want. The question is: are you listening?

Illustration of two people discussing web development, with search bar and website interface elements on an orange background.

The search bar on your website probably doesn’t get the attention it deserves. Yet every time someone types into it, they’re handing you a digital goldmine, which is a live statement of intent. When users search, they know exactly what they want. That moment (those few keystrokes) mark the highest point of buying or engagement intent in the customer journey.

What makes Algolia and Next.js a powerful combination?

Next.js delivers SEO-friendly, lightning-fast pages through server-side rendering. Algolia adds real-time, as-you-type search results. Together, they reduce friction from both search engine entry and on-site discovery, turning search into a seamless, high-converting experience for users.

If your search results are slow, irrelevant, or just “meh,” that intent evaporates. Users bounce. Sales vanish. Market share slips away to someone else whose search actually works.

So, what separates a search that frustrates from a search that converts? It’s architecture.

Today, the combination of Algolia (a lightning-fast, AI-powered search-as-a-service platform) and Next.js (a high-performance React framework from Vercel) forms a conversion architecture built for speed, scalability, and business growth.

Read on to learn:

  1. Why search is no longer a “nice-to-have” but a strategic growth lever.

  2. What makes Algolia + Next.js the dream team for performance and discoverability.

  3. How this pairing was used by FGS Global to revamp a legacy platform into a conversion-ready powerhouse.

  4. And finally, how to future-proof your search with personalization, analytics, and voice search.

Every Search Query is a Sales Signal

When a user types into your site’s search bar, they’re telling you exactly what they want in their own words, and that’s an open door to conversion. If they face poor search experience, it’s a lost opportunity in real time.

When someone uses your search bar, they're at the highest point of purchase intent in their entire journey on your site. They're literally telling you what they want. Yet most businesses treat their search functionality as a feature that just needs to "work."

Smiling man with glasses, beard, and a navy blazer over a white shirt. It's Marcin - co-CEO of Naturaily.

Marcin Sulikowski

co-CEO, Naturaily

Most traditional search implementations fail at precisely this critical moment. They're slow (taking seconds instead of milliseconds), they don't handle typos well (did you mean "running shoes" when you typed "runing sheos"?), and they certainly don't learn from user behavior to get smarter over time.

You're losing your most motivated buyers. And if the experience is slow, clunky, or produces irrelevant results, you’re literally turning customers away at the point of highest intent. The search moment is the highest point of commercial intent in the user journey, and the quality of your search directly mirrors how customer-centric your brand truly is.

sales decorator

Make search work harder for you

Every missed query is lost revenue. Let’s fix that with lightning-fast, conversion-focused search powered by Algolia + Next.js.

Why Algolia and Next.js Are the Winning Duo

A user’s journey from a search engine to your site has two key performance moments:

  1. The initial load — Will they wait for your page to show up?

  2. The first search — Will they find what they came for?

The Algolia + Next.js duo nails both.

Speed and relevance drive conversions. Next.js handles the first half of that equation, ensuring your page loads lightning-fast, optimized for SEO and first impressions. Next.js ensures top-tier Core Web Vitals, and optimized interactivity using SSR, SSG, and ISR strategies. As soon as the page loads, Algolia takes over, powering instant, as-you-type search that predicts user intent.

Through its InstantSearch engine, makes sure results appear in milliseconds, keeping users engaged and in the buying mindset. It knows "iPhone 17" and "iphne 17" are the same thing, so customers find what they want regardless of small mistakes. It also comes with smart filtering, so customers have the results instantly based on the attributes they narrowed down.

In a world where attention spans are shorter than a TikTok clip, milliseconds matter. Modern consumers expect the same experience everywhere. When your site’s search can’t match that level of intelligence or speed, users assume your brand is outdated.

This server-to-client handoff eliminates the two biggest friction points: slow initial loads and sluggish results. The outcome is a continuous, high-performance experience that keeps users engaged, reduces bounce rates, and increases revenue per visit

The "No Results" Goldmine

Beyond what customers search for, modern analytics reveal how they search. Are they using specific product codes (suggesting they know exactly what they want)? Are they using broad category terms (indicating they're in discovery mode)? This intelligence should inform not just your search configuration but your entire digital marketing and merchandising strategy.

One of merchants’ favorite reports in Algolia's analytics dashboard is "Searches with No Results." This is a prioritized list of customer demand that you're not meeting. It's like having customers walk into your store and tell you exactly what they'd buy if only you had it.

Companies use this data to:

  • Identify new product opportunities

  • Discover terminology mismatches (customers searching for "sneakers" when you call them "athletic shoes")

  • Spot emerging trends before competitors.

What's the Return on Investment?

The beautiful thing about investing in search is that the returns are both immediate and measurable. 

Algolia's customers have achieved returns exceeding 350% ROI with optimized search. When we dig deeper into the mechanics of why this happens, the pattern becomes crystal clear. While only 20% of your website visitors typically use search, those who do are 3 to 4 times more likely to convert. 

When search fails, 53% of consumers don't just leave that product behind, but they abandon their entire cart and shop elsewhere. 

Immediate actions you can take

  1. Audit your current search: Try searching your own site. Time how long results take. Search with typos. Try filtering. Experience what your customers experience.

  2. Analyze your metrics: What percentage of visitors use search? What's their conversion rate compared to browsers? How many searches return no results?

  3. Calculate your opportunity: Based on current search usage and conversion rates, what would a 20% improvement mean for your revenue?

What Advanced Strategies Turn “Good Search” Into a Revenue Engine?

Four levers consistently move the needle:

1. Personalization (without creepiness)

Send a (anonymous or logged-in) userToken and track clicks/add-to-cart/conversions. Algolia infers affinities (brand, category, price) and re-ranks in real time so each person sees more of what they tend to choose, which raises CTR and conversions. Keep editorial rules on top.

2. A/B testing for certainty

Test one change at a time, e.g., boost high-margin SKUs, add “description” to searchable attributes, tweak tie-breakers, and judge by a single KPI like CTR, revenue per search, or zero-results rate. Ship the winner, archive the learning, repeat.

3. Voice search where it helps most

Add a mic button, convert speech to text, and run the query through the same index - it’s great for mobile and support journeys. Start with high-intent tasks and expand based on completion rate and zero-results improvements.

4.  Analytics as a weekly ritual

Clear top searches with no results with synonyms, new content, or products. Investigate high-volume queries with low CTR and fix relevance or presentation. Do it cross-functionally with product, marketing, and content.

Case study: How Next.js + Algolia + Storyblok Turned a Legacy Site into an Intent-Driven Discovery Hub

FGS Global, a strategic communications firm, moved from a slow, rigid site with weak search to a modern, composable stack: Next.js for performance and SEO, Algolia for intelligent discovery, and Storyblok for editor-friendly content. Search became “type-aware,” guiding people to profiles, insights, or news based on intent. 

The company was struggling with a legacy website that was holding back their growth. Their content team of 12+ editors was managing over 1,500 content items, but their search functionality was so poor that users couldn't find what they needed.

After implementing the Algolia + Next.js combination, they transformed it into their primary navigation tool. The search became smart enough to understand user intent: searching for a person's name would take you directly to their profile, while searching for a topic would surface relevant articles and insights.

The transformation went beyond simple keyword matching. The new system could dynamically redirect users to the most relevant section based on their query, turning the search bar from a simple query tool into an intelligent content discovery hub.

The Algolia + Next.js Advantage

We started with a simple question: Why is your website's search costing you sales? By now, the answer should be clear. Traditional search approaches simply can't meet modern customer expectations for speed, relevance, and intelligence.

The Algolia + Next.js combination transforms your search bar from a basic utility into a revenue-driving discovery engine that understands intent, learns from behavior, and guides customers to successful outcomes.

Looking for Next.js agency for your next project or have a similar problem to solve? Contact us and see how we can help. 

FAQ

FAQ

Let’s make search your next growth channel

Customers are already telling you what they want. Let’s make sure they actually find it and convert.

More posts in this category